The Ultimate Glock 19 Build Guide: Competition vs. Carry Mods (With Pros, Cons & Holster Compatibility)
Whether you’re building a Glock 19 for competition (USPSA, IDPA) or everyday carry (EDC), modifications can significantly impact performance, reliability, and holster compatibility. Below is a detailed, breakdown of each major upgrade, including pros, cons, and holster considerations.
1. Frame Modifications
Stippling/Grip Tape
- Pros:
- Improves grip (critical for sweaty hands or competition).
- Custom textures (aggressive for competition, moderate for carry).
- Cons:
- Permanent (stippling ruins resale value).
- Some grip tapes (Talon, HandleIt) may peel over time.
- Holster Compatibility:
- Most holsters still fit, but laser stippling near the trigger guard may cause issues.
Undercut Trigger Guard
- Pros:
- Higher grip = better recoil control.
- More comfortable for long shooting sessions.
- Cons:
- Permanent modification.
- Some holsters (especially molded Kydex) may not retain properly.
Magwell Funnel
- Pros:
- Faster reloads (great for competition).
- Adds weight for recoil mitigation.
- Cons:
- Bulkier for concealed carry.
- Some holsters (like AIWB) won’t accommodate larger magwells.
2. Slide & Sights
Optic Cut (RMR, Holosun, SRO)
- Pros:
- Faster target acquisition (especially in competition).
- Improved accuracy at distance.
- Cons:
- Adds cost (optic + milling).
- Some holsters require optic-cut compatibility.
- Holster Notes:
- Competition: Open-top holsters (Safariland, GX Products) work best.
- Carry: Need optic-compatible AIWB (Tier 1, T.Rex Arms).
Aftermarket Sights (Suppressor Height vs. Low-Profile)
- Pros:
- Co-witness with optic (suppressor-height).
- Low-profile better for snag-free carry.
- Cons:
- Taller sights may print more in concealed carry.
Slide Cuts (Windows, Serrations)
- Pros:
- Reduced weight for faster cycling (competition).
- Aesthetic appeal.
- Cons:
- Can weaken slide (rare but possible).
- Some holsters (especially light-bearing) may not fit modified slides.
3. Trigger Upgrades
Competition Trigger (Johnny Glock, Timney, Zev)
- Pros:
- Lighter pull (2.5-3.5 lbs) for faster splits.
- Crisper break & shorter reset.
- Cons:
- May be too light for EDC (safety concern).
- Some IDPA/USPSA divisions ban extreme trigger mods.
Carry-Optimized Trigger (Apex, Overwatch Precision)
- Pros:
- Smoother pull while maintaining safety (4.5-5.5 lbs).
- Reliable for defensive use.
- Cons:
- Not as fast as competition triggers.
Holster Compatibility:
- Most triggers don’t affect holster fit unless shoe is oversized (rare).
4. Barrel & Recoil System
Threaded Barrel (For Compensator or Suppressor)
- Pros:
- Reduced recoil (with comp).
- Future suppressor capability.
- Cons:
- Longer OAL = harder to conceal.
- Some competitions ban compensators (IDPA Carry Optics).
- Holster Issues:
- Standard holsters won’t fit; need threaded barrel or comp-compatible models.
Compensator (PMM, Agency, Zev)
- Pros:
- Flatter shooting (great for competition).
- Cons:
- Adds bulk (bad for carry).
- Requires tuned recoil spring.
Recoil Spring (15-20lb for Comp, Stock for Carry)
- Pros:
- Lighter spring = softer recoil (competition).
- Cons:
- Too light can cause malfunctions in carry guns.
5. Magazine & Baseplate Upgrades
Extended Baseplates (TTI, Henning, Strike Industries)
- Pros:
- +5 rounds (great for competition stages).
- Cons:
- Prints badly in concealed carry.
- Some IDPA rules limit magazine length.
Holster Issues:
- Most competition holsters (BladeTech, CR Speed) accommodate extensions.
- Carry holsters (especially AIWB) may not.
6. Light/Laser for Carry vs. Competition
Carry: Streamlight TLR-7A
- Pros:
- Compact, good holster support.
- Cons:
- Less lumens than X300.
Competition: SureFire X300
- Pros:
- Brighter, more durable.
- Cons:
- Bulkier for carry.
Holster Compatibility:
- TLR-7A: Tier 1, T.Rex, Vedder.
- X300: Safariland, G-Code.
Final Recommendations
Competition Glock 19 Build:
- Optic (SRO/Holosun 507Comp)
- Lightweight slide cuts
- 3.5lb competition trigger
- Magwell + extended basepads
- Compensator (if division allows)
Carry Glock 19 Build:
- RMR/Holosun 507C (closed emitter for dust)
- Stippling (moderate texture)
- Carry trigger (Apex/Overwatch)
- TLR-7A light
- No magwell (for concealment)